|
What is
preimplantation genetic diagnosis (PGD) ?
PGD is the genetic
testing of preimplantation stage embryos produced through In-Vitro
Fertilisation for specific single gene disorders or heritable
chromosomal imbalance. PGD experiments were carried out in the UK in the
1980’s and the first PGD baby was born in 1989. Currently, PGD is only
available at a few clinics worldwide. PGD is not a form of
genetic engineering. The genetic material of the embryos is not
modified.
back to top^
How is PGD carried out?
In-Vitro
fertilization is first carried out to produce the embryos.
Step 1: Ovulation
The mother is given
ovulation-inducing drugs to cause her ovaries to super-ovulate and
release several mature ova at the same time. (Normally, only one
mature ovum is released from either of a woman’s two ovaries every
month, but in super-ovulation, several ova are released all at once.) Drugs that cause super-ovulation contain follicle stimulating
hormone and luteinizing hormone.
Follicle stimulating
hormone stimulates the growth and development of primary follicles each
containing a potential egg cell found in the ovaries. This results in
the formation of Graafian follicles which contain haploid (containing
half the chromosome number i.e.. 23 chromosomes) egg cells. Leutinising
hormone causes ovulation.
Step 2: Egg retrieval
The eggs are
retrieved using either of these 2 methods:
1)
Sonography, where the doctor
places an ultrasound probe in the vagina and guides the aspirating
needle through the wall of the vagina into the follicles of the ovary
using ultrasound to view the position of the ovary, aspiration needle
and follicles. Fluid aspirated out of the follicles in the ovary is
checked under a microscope for the presence of ova. This is a more common
method.
2)
Laparoscopy is used when
sonographic egg retrieval is not possible due to difficulties in
accessing the ovary, or when a diagnostic assessment of the pelvic
organs is required. Here the eggs
are retrieved through an incision in the abdomen. A long, thin
instrument with a light and a lens at the end allows the doctor to
retrieve the ova using an aspiration needle as well as to examine the
pelvic organs by viewing images of these internal organs projected on a
television screen. Carbon dioxide
is put into the abdomen through a special needle that is inserted just
below the navel. This gas helps to separate the organs inside the
abdominal cavity, making it easier for the physician to see the
reproductive organs during laparoscopy. The gas is removed at the end of
the procedure. This procedure is usually carried out under general
anaesthetic.
Step 3: Fertilisation
and incubation
About 1-2 hours after
egg retrieval, the father is asked to produce a semen sample. The eggs
retrieved are placed in a Petri dish together with sperms from the semen
of the father in the ratio of about 1egg : 50000-75000 sperms and are
incubated together at 37 degrees Celsius (normal body temperature) in
carbon dioxide
incubators for 18 hours in a culture media which nourishes the eggs,
and later, the embryos.
Once the embryos
are produced, the actual procedure of PGD begins.
Step 1: Embryo biopsy
3 days after
fertilization has occurred, each successful embryo has divided into
about 4 to 12 cells. One or two cells are removed from the early
multi-celled embryo so that the genetic material in these cells can be
analysed. The removed cell must contain a nucleus with chromosomes
present to determine the genetic status of the rest of the embryo. At
this point, the cells of the embryo are still distinct from each other.
By day four, the embryo begins to compact, a process whereby the
individual cells lose their clear outline and they seem to fuse together
with the other cells to form the morula stage embryo. On the third day,
however, single cells can be individually removed without disrupting the
adjacent cells in the embryo.
Picture shows a 7
cell embryo fixed in position with a holding pipette on the left. A
second pipette on the right is used to drill a hole through the
glycoprotein coat of the embryo, known as the zona pellucida and a cell
is dislodged from the embryo with a gentle suction.
The embryo is
held in a warm culture medium that helps to allow the cells to be
removed with minimum trauma to the embryo during manipulation.
Manipulation is carried out on an inverted microscope. The removal of the cells is
not known to be deleterious to the further development of that embryo,
as the embryo at this early stage of development can compensate for this
loss of material. This is because all cells at this stage are totipotent.
(They are fully capable of directing further embryonic development and
are capable of forming every type of body cell.)
A less
preferred alternative to embryo biopsy is polar body removal. There are
2 polar bodies. The first polar body is produced from the division
of the ovum and can be removed and analysed for its chromosome
complement. Upon penetration of ovum by sperm (i.e. fertilisation)
but before the fusion of their nuclei, the ovum undergoes another cell
division producing 2 cells, one larger than the other. The smaller cell
forms the second polar body while the larger cell's nucleus fuses with
the sperm's nucleus. Polar bodies disintegrate upon implantation and are
not part of the developing foetus. By analysing the genetic material of
the polar bodies, the maternal genetic contribution to the embryo may be
determined. However, results obtained from polar body analysis may not
be conclusive, partly because the paternal genetic contribution will not
be known. In this case embryo biopsy which is more conclusive will have
to be performed.
Step 2: Molecular Analysis
Once a blastomere (a
single cell from the embryo) or polar body is removed, it is either fixed on a glass slide for
chromosomal analysis, or placed in a small tube of chemical buffer for
single gene diagnosis. The cells are then analyzed using techniques
called fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) or DNA analysis using
Polymerase Chain Reaction (PCR) amplification of DNA from single cells.
Fluorescence in-situ hybridization (FISH)
FISH is used for
chromosome analysis to check for sex-linked illnesses, for chromosome
abnormalities like translocation (rearrangement of chromosome in which
part of a chromosome is detached by breakage and is attached to another
chromosome), and for the diagnosis of aneuploidism (the condition of
having less or more than the diploid number of chromosomes i.e.. having
less or more than 46 chromosomes). It allows the visualisation of
specific nucleic acid sequences within a cellular preparation by
incubating a fixed, dried cell containing a nucleus in metaphase or
interphase stage together with a fluorescently labeled gene probe. The fluorescently labeled DNA probes detect or confirm gene or chromosome
abnormalities. The sample DNA is first denatured, a
process that separates the complimentary strands within the DNA double
helix structure. The fluorescently labeled probe of interest is then
added to the denatured sample mixture and hybridizes with the sample DNA
at the target site (i.e. it binds to a specific nucleic acid sequence or
gene of interest) as it reanneals (or reforms itself) back
into a double helix. The probe signal can then be seen through a
fluorescent microscope and the sample DNA scored for the presence or
absence of the signal. If the gene of interest is present, a signal will
be obtained.
During the genetic
analysis, the embryos are usually grown to the fifth day of development
at which time they will be at the morula stage or blastocyst stage.
Those embryos found to be free of genetic abnormalities are then placed
into the uterine cavity.
Morula stage
embryo. The morula contains between 10-30 cells. This is the final stage
before the formation of a fluid filled cavity called the blastocoel
cavity.
Blastocyst stage.
This is attained upon the formation of the blastocoel cavity.
PGD
using FISH on normal male blastomere
Red: chromosome 21. 2 copies are seen here. If 3 copies of this autosome
was present, trisomy 21 (Down’s Syndrome) will result.
White: chromosome Y. Since a Y chromosome is present, the embryo from
which the blastomere is obtained is male.
Green: chromosome 13. 2 copies are seen here. The presence of 3 copies
results in trisomy 13.Trisomy 13, while less common than trisomy 21,
results in mental retardation, and often, heart defects.
Yellow: chromosome X. one copy is seen here.
Blue: chromosome 18. 2 copies are seen here. Presence of 3 copies causes
trisomy 18. Trisomy 18 is less common that both trisomy 21 and trisomy
13. Newborn is usually small for it’s gestational age, is weak and may
have heart defects.
Polymerase Chain Reaction (PCR)
DNA is made up of 4 different bases: adenine, guanine, cytosine and
thymine. The DNA is
denatured at a temperature of 90-96 degrees Celsius. Oligonucleotides
(short nucleotide strands) complementary to the sequence of bases of
interest on the
DNA are produced by automated
chemical synthesis and are used as primers in a special series of
DNA-polymerase catalysed reactions. The primers are annealed (i.e.. they
bind to their complementary sequences on the single strands of DNA) at 50-60
degrees Celsius. DNA polymerisation by a thermostable DNA polymerase is
carried out at
72 degrees Celsius. Starting from the primer, the polymerase can read a
template strand and match it with complementary nucleotides very
quickly. 2 new helices are thus formed in place of the first, with each
new helix comprising of one original strand and one newly assembled
complementary strand. The process may be repeated to produce more DNA,
and each process take only 1-3 minutes. Once the DNA is amplified, the
portions of DNA containing the chromosomes of interest are then analysed
for abnormalities.
DNA amplification is
necessary because a single blastomere will contain only a very small
amount of DNA, and more DNA is required for analysis. Mutation analysis
is carried out using sequence analysis.
refer to table at
http://jmd.amjpathol.org/cgi/content/full/4/1/11/T1 for a look at
the various analytical methods available and the sort of disorders each
method can detect
Embryos found to be free from genetic
and chromosomal abnormalities through FISH and PCR will then undergo
embryo transfer, a 15 minute procedure where a catheter is inserted into
the uterine cavity through the cervical canal. This is performed using
ultrasound guidance. The mother may be given progesterone, a hormone, to nourish and
prepare the wall of the uterus for implantation of the embryo.
Conditions that can
be detected by PGD
1)sex-linked
disorders
Examples of sex-linked disorders:
2)single
gene defects
This is used to identify conditions where the illness is caused by
a single gene that is not functioning normally. These abnormalities may
be detected with molecular techniques using PCR amplification of DNA.
Examples of single gene defects which can be detected by PGD:
-
Cystic fibrosis
-
Tay-Sachs disease
-
Sickle cell anaemia
-
Huntington
disease
3)chromosomal disorders
Chromosomal disorders are caused by inversions (when a chromosome
is broken in 2 places, it heals such that the internal segment is
flipped over), deletions (The loss of chromosomal material) and
translocations (when the ends of 2 different broken chromosomes heal by
attaching to the wrong partner) in chromosomes. These can be detected
using FISH. Chromosomally unbalanced embryos tend to be miscarried
spontaneously, so couples who have never achieved a viable pregnancy may
want to undergo IVF and use PGD to test potential embryos for such
disorders.
back to top^
Who will benefit from PGD?
1) Women
with a history of miscarriages
Foetuses with chromosomal abnormalities tend to be miscarried. PGD will reduce the risk of chromosomal abnormalities in the
foetus by testing it in the embryonic stage for certain detectable
chromosomal abnormalities. Hence women whose history of miscarriages are
due to chromosomal abnormalities of the foetuses will benefit.
2)Carriers of
single
gene disorders, chromosome translocations or other abnormalities
The carrier may be either parent, or both parents. PGD reduces the
risk of having a child with the above-mentioned conditions because some
of these conditions may be detected at the embryo stage using PGD.
3)Parents with personal histories of prenatal diagnosis followed
by termination of foetuses
These parents have a higher chance of
producing babies with foetal abnormalities. They may not want to have to
endure the trauma of another pregnancy termination and may wish to
undergo PGD.
4)People who have moral or religious objections to the
termination of pregnancy.
back to top^
Advantages of PGD
1) Most genetic testing nowadays is done through either
amniocentesis (more common) or chronic villus sampling. Amniocentesis is
done when the foetus is between 11-15 weeks old. It is an invasive
procedure where a needle is inserted into the mother’s uterus in order
to draw up some amniotic fluid containing foetal cells so that
chromosomal analysis may be performed. Amniocentesis carries with it a
small risk of miscarriage. Chronic villus sampling is performed around
the third month of pregnancy. Using ultrasound, a thin hollow tube is
inserted through the vagina and cervix (transvaginal/transcervical) or through the
abdomen (transabdominal) to the edge of the placenta where a tissue
sample is taken for chromosomal analysis. Should the foetus be found to
have certain defects, the parents then have the choice of terminating
the pregnancy. However, with a rather advanced pregnancy, the emotional
trauma of undergoing an abortion may be very great. With PGD however,
the chromosomal analysis is done before pregnancy, since embryos are
tested for abnormalities before being inserted into the uterus. Parents
will not be faced with the difficult decision of whether or not to
undergo an abortion.
Chronic Villus sampling
Amniocentesis
2) Adults who know that they are carriers for certain genetic
conditions may undergo PGD to ensure that their children will
not suffer from that condition.
3) Will significantly
reduce the medical costs because certain diseases require expensive
medication and treatment throughout an individual’s lifetime
4) There will be a
reduced risk of miscarriage as only embryos without chromosomal
abnormalities which can currently be detected through PGD are inserted
into the uterus.
back to top^
Disadvantages of PGD
1) Instead of using PGD to
detect the presence of genetic diseases and chromosomal abnormalities,
parents may also use PGD to select the gender of the baby. This may
cause gender imbalance, especially in countries like India and China
where there is a strong preference for male children.
2)
Parents may also use PGD to
select embryos having certain genetic traits which they consider
desirable. This may be perceived as practicing some form of eugenics.
3)PGD is very
expensive.
4)A couple who can
conceive naturally will be required to undergo IVF, an expensive
procedure with no guarantee of success should they want PGD.
5) If PGD is carried
out using PCR, there is a risk of contamination from cellular sources.
This contains whole genomic DNA. There is also a risk of carry over
contamination from products of former PCR reactions. These will give
rise to inaccurate results.
6)During PCR, allele
dropout, where an affected allele fails to amplify may occur. This will
create problems for the correct diagnosis of autosomal dominant
diseases.
7)
People of some religions
believe that life begins at conception. They have a 2 main concerns
regarding PGD:
-
The cell which is removed could become a
foetus on its own, since it is totipotent. However, the testing will destroy it.
-
Fertilized cells which are not stored
for future use are either destroyed or donated for research, and
therefore will die
back to top^
Some relevant and useful
websites
http://www.rgi2.com/pgd.html
Contains
information on PGD, including the details of polar body analysis and
blastomere biopsy, as well as disorders that can be diagnosed with PGD
and pitfalls of PGD.
http://www.bionews.org.uk/update.lasso?storyid=1639
Contains articles about the ethical and legal issues surrounding PGD
http://health.allrefer.com
Details and pictures of some of the various medical procedures described can
be found here. In addition, details some of the various diseases
mentioned above may be
obtained too.
http://jmg.bmjjournals.com/cgi/content/full/39/1/6
A review article found in the online Journal of Medical Genetics.
Elaborates on the various medical procedures and reasons behind PGD.
http://www.ich.ucd.ac.uk/cmgs/fishpgd.htm
An article about FISH studies of pre-implantation embryos. Useful links
provided under the reference section.
http://www.trisomy.org
Brochures in literature section contain more information about trisomy 13 and
trisomy 18.
http://opbs.okstate.edu/~melcher/MG/MGW4/MG42.html
Contains methods of DNA analysis.
|